Archive of South Asia Citizens Wire | feeds from sacw.net | @sacw
Home > Communalism Repository > India: Progressive Muslim Voices and Concerned Citizens Slam Clerics, Court (...)

India: Progressive Muslim Voices and Concerned Citizens Slam Clerics, Court Ruling on Section 377

18 December 2013

print version of this article print version

India: ‘Section 377 must be scrapped’ - Muslim progressive voices

December 16, 2013

URGENT: Press release

‘Section 377 must be scrapped’

We, the undersigned, are shocked by the Supreme Court verdict which, instead of affirming the fundamental constitutional principle of non†discrimination between citizens, criminalises homosexuality. We stand with the national and global community of LGBT individuals and organisations, human rights and civil liberties groups, the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights and democratic governments in damning the regressive ruling which reduces India to a lesser, narrow†minded, intolerant democracy.

We demand immediate action from legislators across the political spectrum for scrapping the obnoxious Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code – a legacy of the colonial era – to decriminalise same sex relations between consenting adults. We applaud political leaders and parties which have spoken out against the apex court’s ruling.

We condemn the shameful support of the latest verdict by leaders from the BJP (including its prime ministerial aspirant) and the Samajwadi Party, and silence on the issue by some other parties.

We call upon religious leaders from different faiths – who had spoken with one voice against the earlier progressive ruling of the Delhi High Court and who are now celebrating the judgment of the Supreme Court – to reflect upon the wise words of Pope Francis: “Who are we to judge?†In his paradigm†shifting interview in September, the Pope has bemoaned the fact the Catholic Church was “obsessed†with the issue of homosexuality. We urge the high priests of other religions too to exorcise themselves of the same obsession.

We would like to remind religious leaders that India is a secular democracy, not a theocracy.

While the clergy is entitled to its views on what does or does not constitute a sin, it must realise that in a democracy punishments are only prescribed for crimes, not for sins. So they should stop playing god.We emphatically assert that same sex relations between consenting adults is not a crime and those engaging in it are no less human than heterosexuals. They must be respected as equals. Leave alone their being treated as criminals, any kind of discrimination against them is entirely unacceptable.
Issued on behalf of signatories by

JAVED ANAND HASINA KHAN
(Muslims for Secular Democracy) (Muslim Women’s Rights Network)
+919870402556 +919870162113

SIGNATORIES:
MUMBAI
1. Nandita Das
2. Mohammed Zubair Saifi
3. Noorjehan Safia Naaz, Bhartiya Muslim Mahila Andolan
4. Irfan Engineer
5. Vahida Nainar, Women’s Research and Action group
6. Sameera Khan
7. Anjum Rajabali
8. Awaaz†e†Niswaan
9. Sabah Khan †Muslim women’s rights Network
10. P.K. Shajahan, Tata Institute of Social Science
11. Aquila Khan
12. Farrukh Waris
13. Sukla Sen, Committee for Communal Amity (Ekta)
14. Jyoti Punwani
15. Vrijendra
16. Rohini Hensman
17. Ram Puniyani
ALLAHABAD
18. Zafar Bakht
19. Shooby Bakht
20. Anshu Malviya
21. Utpala Shukla
CHENNAI
22. Kasim Sait
23. Kareem Sait
24. Dr Zaheer Ahmed Sayeed
25. Farhan Shaikh
DELHI
26. Noor Zaheer
27. Zakia Soman, Bhartiya Muslim Mahila Andolan
28. Dilip Simeon
29. Sonia Jabbar
30. Jamal Kidwai
31. Ira Singh
32. Nasiruddin Hyder
HYDERABAD
33. Jameela Nishat, Shaheen Women Resource & Welfare Association (Hyderabad).
34. Asma Begum, Shaheen Women Resource & Welfare Association (Hyderabad).
35. Mazher Hussain (Hyderabad).
LUCKNOW
36. Salim Kidwai
37. Hamida Khatoon, Sanatkada
38. Fauzia Khan, AALI
OTHER
39. Rebecca Kurian (Bangalore)
40. Dhirendra Sharma, (Dehradun, UP)
41. Reshma Bohra Sahiyar (Gujarat)
42. Azma Aziz, Muhim (Farrukhabad, UP)
43. Shadab Jahan, Astitva, (Muzaffarnagar, UP)
44. Rupina Patel Muslim Mahila Manch, (Nagpur)
45. Anvar Rajan, Pragatisheel Muslim Andolan (Pune)
46. Ghulam Mohiyuddin (New York, USA)
47. Najid Hussain (USA)
48. Javid Syed (New York, USA)
49. Mohammed Imran
50. G. T. Verghese
51. A. Mani
52. Nirupa Bhangar
53. Nazma Iqbal, Pehchan Samajik Sanstha (Uttarakhand)
54. Fatima Shahroz, (UP)